How to Get Witch Fingers in Grow a Garden: Trick-or-Treat Odds

Witch Fingers is a Legendary plant seed in Grow a Garden, the Roblox farming game where you grow crops and sell what they make. You get it from the Trick-or-Treat house during the Halloween event, where you pay Candy Corn for a try and hope for a Treat, since only a Treat can drop the seed. The seed isn't sold in the regular Seed Shop, so the house is where you'll need to go.

Detail	What to know
Rarity	Legendary
Where to get it	Trick-or-Treat house during the Halloween event
First try cost	10 Candy Corn
Price change	Doubles after each try, resets after eight hours
Treat or Trick	80% Treat, 20% Trick
Seed chance	7%, on a Treat only

How the Trick-or-Treat House Works in Grow a Garden

Each try follows the same steps:

Head to the Trick-or-Treat house during the Halloween event and interact with it.
Pay the Candy Corn price shown on screen.
Wait for the result. Eight in ten tries land a Treat, and the other two are Tricks.
On a Treat, the game rolls for the seed, which has a 7% chance to drop.

Grow a Garden Halloween event house with a Trick or Treat prompt showing a 10 Candy Corn cost and a View Rewards sign.

A Trick doesn't roll for the seed at all, so a Treat has to come up before the seed can drop. Think of it as two checks in a row. The house decides Treat or Trick first, and only on a Treat does the seed roll decide whether you get the plant.

How Each Try Changes the Price at the Trick-or-Treat House

Your first try costs 10 Candy Corn, and every try after that doubles the price. A quick run of tries gets expensive fast. The price drops back to 10 once the eight-hour reset passes, so waiting it out keeps your costs low, and timing your tries matters as much as how many you make.

Earning Candy Corn at the Sinister Sales Stand

Every try at the house takes Candy Corn, so your stock decides how many tries you can make. Selling Halloween crops at the Sinister Sales stand adds Candy Corn to that stock. You choose when to sell, so you can build up enough before a run of tries and start them once the price is back at 10.

Planting Witch Fingers Once You Have the Seed

Once you have a Witch Fingers seed, plant it the way its tooltip describes.

Grow a Garden Trick or Treat Rewards panel showing the Witch Fingers seed reward and a Legendary Witch Fingers planting tooltip.

FAQ

Do I lose all my Candy Corn if I get a Trick?

No. A Trick returns 25% of the Candy Corn you paid, so you lose the other 75%. Plan for that loss before you pay for a run of tries, since most of the cost is still gone after a Trick.

How much does four tries cost?

It depends on timing. Four tries in a row cost 150 Candy Corn, since the price goes 10, 20, 40, and 80. If you wait out the eight-hour reset between each try, the same four tries cost 40 Candy Corn, because every one starts back at 10.

What are the odds of getting Witch Fingers on one try?

About 5.6%. A Treat comes up 80% of the time, and the seed rolls at 7% on a Treat, so 80% × 7% is about 5.6% on any single try. That works out to roughly one seed for every 18 tries on average, but that's only an average under these rules, not a guarantee. You could land it on your first try or need far more.

About Pragna Sanisetty

An avid Roblox player who loves exploring the small, niche games that quietly show up in my recommendations. I track new Roblox codes across social platforms and update them on Bloxodes as soon as they drop. I prefer writing guides based on real gameplay experience instead of plain surface level info, so players get tips that actually help in game. My favorite Roblox game is Egg Farm Simulator.